Wednesday, October 31, 2012

Does Format Matter?

I know what you are thinking (at least I think so) based on this week's title "Does Format Matter?"--like, duh Kim, of course it matters :o) but there are different kinds of format organization and as teachers, at least I know this is true for me, I would emphasize different types of format over others depending upon the subject areas I was teaching. In my mind, I had so much work to accomplish with the students and so little time, that I would weigh what was more important and make adjustments from there.

For example, have you been in a situation where students will turn in assignments or notes for credit that are not written in complete sentences and allowed that depending on the subject area? What I mean is, if a student gave you short responses in say science, is that okay?

Generally speaking, students have been given the message (perhaps through past classes and with former teachers) that it is okay to express their knowledge in a variety of formats--that fit the situation. Sounds good so far, right? What student's say though is just as important as how they communicate it. Think about how important subject verb agreements are, proficient grammar, etc, in not only school situations, but also on the job, and other life situations. That ability to express him/herself effectively is critical to a variety of society demands.

So this week's questions are...do you correct students syntax, grammar, usage, etc. when you students study in all subject areas or is that focus primarily in English/Language Arts? Is it possible to hold students to using complete sentences and proper grammar all of the time? What are the benefits to doing so? What are the challenges?

7 comments:

  1. Format matters depending on the standard being addressed. If the purpose of your assignment is to evaluate just thoughts and a student's ability to express understanding of a standard, then format is not as important. However, when working in online format where most responses are written, it would be beneficial to ask students to write using complete sentences when the teacher wants to also focus on writing standards. With that said, if ELA teachers were constantly editing for syntax and grammar, the grading would be overwhelming. A balance needs to be met.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think it's important that all disciplines work together and use every opportunity as a teaching moment. As an English instructor, I'm always on guard for grammar issues. At the same time, I'm not using the red pen on everything. I want to make sure that the students feel comfortable in trying as well. If every mistake is pointed out, then we risk discouraging the student. If we give them hints, tips, and suggestions over time; they'll be much more responsive to learning and will hopefully find it encouraging as well. I think it should be the same in other disciplines. It's all academic and needs to be held at an academic standard no matter what the discipline. If I have something related to history in my English course, I want to make sure the historical facts are correct. It actually helps the students learn the topics even better when they're repeated in the different subjects.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I teach core math, statistics, and physics. In all classes I require students to answer in complete sentences. This goes back to my having high expectations for my students. I always want them to explain their steps and what they were thinking. Explaining shows a more solid level of understanding than if they only gave a numerical answer. For example, in statistics it's not enough for me that they write "30" for their answer. They have to provide me with an explanation such as:

    The mean of the data set is 30. I got this by adding up all five values and dividing by 5. This is what I did:
    (10 + 20 + 30 + 40 + 50)/5 = 30


    I agree with Jesse that "it's important that all disciplines work together". Students need to practice their writing skills in all classes, even in math. It just makes sense to me. I also prefer to keep email communication more formal as well. If I receive an email that resembles "texting" or that has too many errors, I will tell them that I can't understand what they wrote. I'll ask them to try again, take their time writing and use their spell-checker.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I enjoyed reading all of your responses. As an English teacher, format is definitely something the discipline requires. The more formal the assignment, the more strict I am on format. For example, if the assignment is a reading comprehension or vocabulary assignment that can be answered in a simple sentence, I will not be as strict if the student answers in a phrase. However, if the assignment is a major writing assignment, which is a formal essay, I will be very strict on grammar and format.

    In addit

    ReplyDelete
  6. It is absolutely critical to make sure that students have proper form and grammar when completing assignments. If we are preparing students for college, we need to hold them to a higher standard. If we don't they will definitely have a wake up call in when they enroll in higher education.

    Substance is also really important. If I can see that a student put thought into his/her assignment and supported it with details, I would give them a high mark. With that being said, I would still mark them down for grammatical errors.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Do you correct students syntax, grammar, usage, etc. when you students study in all subject areas or is that focus primarily in English/Language Arts? Is it possible to hold students to using complete sentences and proper grammar all of the time? What are the benefits to doing so? What are the challenges?
    I do believe that students should be using correct English in their responses in all classes. This gives them a good reason to learn correct English, and it is what would be expected in their higher education or career. But another reason that is important to me, is that this shows a higher level of conscientiousness in their work. It shows that they haven't just rushed through the assignment, without taking the time to check their work, spell correctly, or think about sentence structure. One of the benefits is that using correct grammar will show respect for their work and another is that it will make them review their work, being more conscious of the response as they think about its form.
    This expectation should be communicated with the assignments of the course. Students who have special circumstances could be allowed some leeway, as long as the expectations are encouraging them to show eventual proficiency in English.

    ReplyDelete