Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Teaching without Apologies

 
Sometimes when we talk to students (at least this is true for me) about school expectations, class expectations, lesson expectations, it is easy to brush over important information or communicate in a manner that inadvertently lowers those expectations. When I talk about teaching without apologies, I'm talking about being passionate about the subjects we teach--for not apologizing for teaching worthy content--even if it isn't our favorite subjects(s). Sometimes the least interesting subject to us can be the life-changing subject for a student.

So, let's talk about this some..is there a such thing as boring content? Can all content be presented in a way to engage students--to inspire them? What happens if the teacher is in doubt that he/she can make a subject or lesson come alive?

Some ways some instructors inadvertently lower expectations (Do you agree or disagree?):
  1. "Thinking content is boring is a self-fulfilling prophecy"
  2. "Blaming content on some outside entity"
  3. "Making content so accessible that the content is diluted"
  4. "Assuming content is too difficult for students"
What are some techniques you use to get students excited about content?

7 comments:

  1. Good afternoon,

    This is a very interesting topic considering that it's one I'm dealing with at another position as we speak. I'm teaching Comp II for a college near by. The students have already covered the material for this course in Comp I; the students have politely stressed to me their boredom. This particular location requires that I stick with the curriculum with no wiggle room. This makes it very difficult as an instructor. It makes it difficult when we don't have the option to own the material or to make it our own. We have to find a way to believe in it ourselves. In this course, one of the chapters mentions finding a topic for a research paper and find a way to make it interesting. I think this can be an analogy for this situation as well. If I'm teaching students how to make a topic interesting, by finding a unique angle, I must do the same thing and practice what I teach! We have to find a way to make it interesting, even with the odds are against us, or the self-fulling prophecy will take affect; we'll lose interest, lower the expectations, and our students will pick up on this.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I guess the easiest way to get students excited or interested in content is to be excited ourselves, but that is part of the problem we are thinking about.

    I definitely teach subjects that I'm not the biggest fan of and one way I get around "boring" periods in history is by helping the student make connections to topics they (I'm) interested in.

    I think this is a little easier for me in history courses, but I think it can work in other courses as well. Yea maybe the industrial revolution was kind of boring, but look what it led to! The expansion of western civilization all over the globe and a huge struggle to become the most powerful empire. I think connections are an easy way to spark interest.

    I feel for your situation Jesse where you are kind of tied to the content, but maybe you can find interesting examples of poor research or techniques. Or something where you kind of take the opposite approach and show why they are learning what is included in Comp II.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I can see how some parts of some standards may be "lack luster" to some. I have also noticed fellow educators spending less time on these parts of the curriculum because it may not be there favorite part to cover.

    I believe that every teacher has areas in which they tend to not feel as strongly about. This is why professional development is so important. It is up to each educator to find what works not just for them, but also for students. Many teachers feel that students get bored with certain areas. Because of this, they might spend less time on that chapter.

    Here is the good news. There are many resources and organizations out there where teachers can look to and get ideas. This is how we get better. I can't tell you how many times I have gotten energized after attending a training that directly influenced my ability to teach. It is up to each teacher to seek this out.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I teach math and I frequently encounter these comments: "this is boring" or "When do I use it in real life?" I agree with Jeb that if I am excited as a teacher then most of my students will respond in the same manner. Even on the days that I don't feel like teaching a certain concept, if I act excited then my students will get excited about the material and after a while I find myself more energized.Another approach is to connect the mathematical concepts to everyday life experiences of the students. This is not a very easy task. Using word problem is often a good way of establishing this connection. And if I have doubts about teaching a certain concept then I can always consult with a colleague or a more experienced teacher.

    ReplyDelete
  5. My students definitely favor certain topics more than others. For example, many students struggle with Shakespeare and his use of Old English. I have noticed that their responses to assignments for Shakespeare are more general and brief. I believe this is due to the difficulty of the language.

    I have told students that Shakespeare's story lines are fascinating and to not become discouraged by the difficulty of the readings. Sometimes I point them to abridged versions of the play where they can read the plays in modern English but still enjoy the complex story lines.

    This is one example where I try to keep their interest in a topic that they might otherwise find as boring.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I agree that it is helpful if the instructor is passionate about the topic, but this doesn't always create student interest. Students sometimes do not participate because they do not understand what is going on and/or are afraid that they are wrong. In the online classroom, it is difficult to overcome this fear when answers are permanently in print when posted. A way to circumvent the fear, is to hold virtual chats where students and teacher can discuss the concepts before students have to commit anything to print. Sometimes students need reassurance from peers and/or the teacher that they are on the right track before taking the risk to post ideas.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I have heard so many adults talk about their schooling, and most will remember a particular teacher who was very strict (in the sense of content standards) or a class that was really challenging. Many will say something like, "When I first started the class I didn't know what was going on (didn't like it, etc.), but at the end I could actually enjoy the poems (or understand what it was like to live during that period in history, etc.).
    When I read the prompt for teaching without apologies, these memories came to mind.
    Teachers need to teach their particular subject with commitment, even if students are not at the point to understand the significance in the beginning. We also need to work at getting students to make the connections from the course content to their future needs, and build into the course reasons to learn.

    ReplyDelete