How do you go about motivating the student who responds, but only provides a partially correct answer? Is there a difference between effort and mastery? What kinds of positive language do you use with students to push them all the way to a fully correct response?

I believe that you can find something positive in nearly all submitted assignments. Thus, I try to motivate students by telling them something positive from their submissions. I use these positive statements to segue into areas in which they can improve.
ReplyDeleteMy comments include suggestions on how they can build upon the positive aspects of their assignment and suggestions on how to improve their weaker points.
I have found this to be much more effective and motivating for students than just telling them what was wrong with their English paper. Providing students with positive feedback, along with corrective suggestions, encourages students to revise and re-submit for a better grade.
I definitely agree with Jimmy! I think that positive reinforcement not only gets the most out of a student on a current assignment, but also impacts their future work. I give positive feedback on nearly every assignment I grade. I want the student to know what they are doing well, but I also want them to recognize where they need to grow.
ReplyDeleteWhen it comes to positive reinforcement I like to comment on unique ideas or perspectives. This may be easier in social studies, but I always get a response when I tell a student that they had and "interesting thought" or "good observation". These also make it easy for me to move into more of a questioning mode. What made you think of that? What about this? How do you explain this?
I think that by telling them what they are doing well in the beginning makes them more willing to use the critical feedback that follows.
When it comes to effort and mastery, there is definitely a difference. I don't expect any of my students to master a topic, I also try to let them know that I am still learning. I think it really motivates a student when you let them know that their thoughts made you think!
A lot depends on the words we use. For math I use different phrases such as:
ReplyDelete-- That's a good plan. Now go ahead and solve it.
-- Those are all good ideas, so let's see your solution.
-- I can tell you understand this. Now you just need to show your work so you can earn the points.
-- You're on the right track, but don't forget to...
-- Parts one and three are great, now for part two...
-- Everything looks great. There's just one tiny mistake... If you fix it you'll earn full credit.
-- You're almost there. I think you forgot the last step of... If you revise one more time you'll earn 100%.
I agree with everyone on this one. I always believe in the balance between what's right and what's motivating. I always praise the student first for taking a shot at an answer. After that, work with them to develop the correct answer. If I find that they're not going to get to the correct answer, even with my assistance, I state would another student like to take it a step further.
ReplyDeleteJess
I believe that I good teacher helps to guide students in the right direction. It is also our job to push them in order to get the best out of them. I would also agree that it is important to praise students like Jesse stated. After this, it is important to articulate what you want them to answer but to also make sure they discover it by themselves.
ReplyDeletePosted on behalf of Jolene Ericsson...
ReplyDeleteI agree that when we are within a letter grade of one another the results are not alarming. There is always room for objectivity and each teacher may tend to focus on grade level emphasis. However, if a student is given a rubric beforehand, the teacher should be able to grade and give feedback that closely follows the rubric guidelines.
One thing I learned from a recent professional development training, is to thank students for answering. First the student is thanked for the response regardless of whether it is 100% correct or not. Then the correct part of the response is acknowledged. After that, additional questions can be asked until the fully correct answer is given. The next step is to ask similar questions until the teacher can be sure that the students have understood the concept.
ReplyDeleteThis process rewards students for taking the risk to respond. The additional questions help to clarify the thinking process used to get to the correct response. And the similar questions provide a check for understanding.