Thursday, October 11, 2012

Student Work Sample Review and Discussion

 
Here they are everyone....the results from the English / Language Arts and Mathematics Student Work Samples! Take a look at the attachment in your email and answer the following questions:
  • What does this data tell us?
  • What does it not tell us?
  • What do we need to work on?
  • What techniques do you use to measure student learning in your class?
  • How do you use those results?

10 comments:

  1. This data, to me, tells us that we are in close correlation with our grading techniques on most of the sample assignments, and there a few where it's completely across the board. I don't get too many red flags when we're in a couple of letter grades of each other, but I do get curious when there are several A's, B's, D's, and F's. I also noticed, especially for the English portion and maybe it's because I teach English, we each focus on different areas and have different areas that we stress where the student should focus their work, according to the comments; some of us focus on the thesis statement, the topic sentence, the grammar, or the transitions. I personally try to keep each of the major areas in mind, and having a rubric for English is important, or it becomes subjective, to some degree. For me personally, I also grade a little more on the strict side, and that's because I allow students to resubmit assignments. I feel it's an excellent way for them to learn. They get to see what corrections need to be made, how they can improve, and hopefully it helps them with writing in the long run. This also puts the ultimate responsibility, as far as what grade they will get, because they have the option to improve. I think it would affect my grading to some degree if I did not allow them to resubmit assignments. I would probably be a little be a little more lenient (not much), because I know it's their only chance for the assignment.

    Jess

    ReplyDelete
  2. For the most part, it looks like grading was uniform (within a grade level). There were a couple of samples that varied such as #4 and #6. These two had a wider range of scores.

    I tend to focus on the literary analysis of an essay. I like to see students include specific evidence from the text (concrete detail) to support their assertions. I also look for commentary that is insightful and connected to their specific evidence. In addition, their conclusion must logically flow from their analysis. I do point out spelling and grammar errors if they are so severe that they take away from the overall quality of the paper. If it is only a missing comma or other minor grammar error, I won't grade them down too harshly.

    Like Jess, I allow students to revise for full credit. I find the biggest error is that student make general statements and conclusions without support from specific evidence. Overall, I have been impressed with the quality of writing from NUVHS students.

    ReplyDelete
  3. What surprised me the most was how the scores on the ELA samples generally varied by +/- one letter grade, whereas the math scores were all over the place. So what happened with math? One reason might be that no rubric was provided, so it's important that we have rubrics. But I'm still not sure how a sample that I graded as an F (because it was incomplete and not correct) can receive an A or B from another instructor. Perhaps those high grades were for effort rather than mastery? I don't know.

    For our math courses I am adding what I'm calling "Big Ideas" assignments where students solve a multi-step real-world problem. These are end-of-unit assignments where students are required to use concepts and skills from several lessons. They have to provide a written explanation for their solution as well as provide supporting information such as theorems/postulates, graphs, drawings, formulas, algebra steps, etc. Typically these will be 1-2 page assignments written in Microsoft Word. I think these assignments will help math instructors better assess student learning.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I have almost the same reaction as Marianne to the samples. Samples that I gave a low grade received high marks. I don't think we can give that much partial credit or points just for effort if the student has no mastery of the concept. We need to have uniform and systematic rubrics for grading. In my classes I only give partial credit if I can see that the student was on the right track in solving the problems. Student performance on different assessments and their projects is one good method to measure their learning.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I would agree with the majority of the other teachers. Rubrics help to keep grading consistent among the teachers. I think it is difficult to grade for effort. Many teachers will have a different opinion of what that might look like.

    Kim mentioned about giving points for showing work on Math problems. I think that it would be a good idea to give students partial credit for showing some of the steps to answer a question (even if the answer is wrong.)

    ReplyDelete
  6. When it came to the language arts samples we were all pretty close to each other and this is probably because of the presence of the rubric, but the math samples kind of shocked me. It looks like everyone is in agreement about the results for the math assignments and the wide range of grades awarded. I don’t think this question really needed a rubric though because the question is stated pretty clearly and the student is told to explain how they came to their conclusion.
    When I look at the data for the math samples it makes me wonder what the grading guidelines are for math assignments and if effort/attempt of the problem is to be awarded. I do feel students should receive partial credit for effort, but only if they are on the right track and still following the directions. After reviewing this data I think it would be good to reflect on our own grading. What is important to us when it comes to our students and what they take away from the course? How can we best fit our expectations with the standards set by the state?
    I think it is interesting to think about each teacher and their own grading philosophy especially when we get to see how we all grade the same work. I know that from a social studies perspective I grade on effort all the time. I’m less concerned about perfect grammar and the student coming to the same conclusion as me or what is most commonly held as true. I am most interested in the student showing me that they are thinking and using research and evidence to come to their own conclusions. Obviously this doesn’t work for all subjects.
    I have been allowing revisions in my courses as well and I use this as a teaching moment. I want the students to understand what I am looking for and why they are receiving the grade they earned. For the most part I feel my students use the feedback to grow and submit stronger assignments through the course, but I have come across some situations where it seems like students are simply taking advantage of this policy and not putting forth their best effort from the beginning.
    After thinking about these results, I am definitely going to make sure I have consistent expectations for all assignments and that my directions are clear. I may even start to incorporate rubrics for all assignments to make sure all expectations are visible to the students.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Revisions are important since writing is a process. A method that I use when teaching is to have a formative and summative grading rubric that excludes letter grades.

      Formative: Traditional letter scores of B-C- get 85% of the points, if a student is in the A column, the student gets 95% of the points.

      Traditional letter scores of: D-F get 65% ofthe points.

      Summative: Traditional letter scores of A-B: 95% of the points
      Traditional letter scores of C-C- get 75% of the points
      Traditional letter scores of D-F get 65% of the points

      Formative essays: Students get unlimited rewrites
      Summative essays: Students do not get to rewrite since these are supposed to demonstrate mastery. The hope is that students will ask for teacher feedback before due date.

      It might be out of our comfort zones as teachers to not give letter grades, but this helps to ease the anxiety of students when writing. They are able to see strengths and weakness and use the rubric comments as a tool to improve. This is something you might want to try...I love it and my students have been responsive.

      Delete
  7. While the language arts scores are within in range, it is interesting that teachers valued different components of the writing process which resulted in the range discrepancy. A solution to this, would be to consider weighting different components of the writing process as more valuable. Therefore, when marking the rubric, teachers subjective views would have less of an impact because the rubric weight for each writing process category would determine the overall grade. This would need to be a discussion that all of the writing teachers have with each other. Has anyone considered having a common rubric that all NUVHS uses? This would provide consistency through the grade levels for expectations in writing. The terminology would be the same but the product expectations would increase based on grade level and expected level of skill. Another way we could calibrate our grading is to get sample anchor essays that we all agree are high, medium and low level samples. Writing is a process that is difficult to master and difficult to grade. It is hard to not bring in your subjective views; therefore, it is important to have a common rubric/common language among teachers so that there is equity for students.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I want to make sure this is working first. Let's try to post.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Ok so it went through. So I was really interested in the results. The short of it is that a few things need to be clarified. First we need to make sure that the standards are the same for all classes. Once that is done then we can set a rubric so that we can grade the outcomes we want. For something like language arts it is important to ask what we need them to be able to do. The department needs to be clear what happens if there is no thesis statement. Does the student get marked off? I think this is a good way of making sure there is much more uniformity of grading.

    ReplyDelete