One thing you have
probably heard over and over again is that "...high expectations are the most reliable
driver of high student achievement, even in students who do not have a history
of successful achievement." A lot of the research that backs this claim is in
regards to testing where in which two sets of students were tested--one in which
the teachers held high expectations for students and the other set where the
teachers did not emphasize those same expectations.
One thing that
studies (like the one described above) doesn't explain is that they often assume
there are commonly held actions, beliefs, and operational strategies involved
with attaining those expectations. Some may claim that additional time on a
subject matter is sufficient (for example), but how do we really analyze and
identify that extra time as a viable solution that impacts learning and
ultimately achievement? What are some of the actions, beliefs, and strategies
that you have been successful with?
In your experience,
what are some concrete ways that you have been able to attain results through
having high expectations?

I teach math and physics. I just got through emailing 20 of my math students to go back and re-work their assignments to earn 100% scores. I made sure to CC all of their parents as well.
ReplyDeleteHere are some things I do:
1. My courses have a "Guidelines" page that describes what I expect with every type of assignment. I refine this list throughout the term.
2. My courses have a "Recommendations" page that describes how best to work in the online course. This page is a compilation of what seems to work well for students.
3. For any assignment that is not properly formatted I assign a zero score and bounce it back right away. I won't even look at the content.
4. For any assignment that is incomplete, I assign a zero score and bounce it back. Even if they answered 9 out of 10 questions, I will still ask them to complete it before I grade it.
5. For an assignment that is very good but can still be a little better, I will often assign half credit (or 75%) and bounce it back again.
As long as I provide a lot of feedback (specific feedback), students will almost always revise their work. It's only at the end of the term when they've run out of time when they cannot revise.
I like many of Marianne's ideas especially the guidelines and recommendations pages. I have actually been planning on adding similar pages to my course.
ReplyDeleteAs far as my methods for setting my expectations, I try to set the tone early in the course. I never directly state what I expect, but I grade assignments and provide specific feedback to highlight the type of information that is being looked for, how the responses should be supported.
I hope that my detailed feedback shapes not only future work, but what they expect from themselves while completing assignments.
I haven't taken the plunge and given the zero for incomplete work or assignments not completed in the proper format. How does that work for you Marianne? Do the students respond well?
Hey Jeb, as you mentioned it's important to set the tone right away at the start of the term starting with unit 1.
DeleteIt's also important to follow up with emails to the individual and the whole class ("Everyone, please remember to look over the Guidelines page. It describes how assignments should be submitted. Please revise and resubmit your work. I cannot assign your credit otherwise.") By emailing the entire class, students know that I have the same expectations for everyone.
As long as my expectations are clear, students don't seem to mind my "strict" policy at all. :)
I do many of the things Marianne does such as allowing students to revise assignments that do not meet the criteria for full credit. I do this for standard assignments as well as Major Writing Assignments.
ReplyDeleteMost students are eager to revise and submit for full credit. If a student wishes to do so, they can also email the assignment for corrections before they submit to the drop box. I suppose the counter argument to doing this is that it leads to grade inflation since most students will receive full credit after revisions.
However, I feel it is more important for students to master content and I feel comfortable giving a high grade if a student has earned full credit after revisions.
After a few units, students grow accustomed our high standards. I think this is what makes online teaching unique in that we are able to give individualized instruction to ensure that students are proficient before moving on to the next unit.
I enjoyed reading everyone's comments.... Jimmy
Posted on behalf of Farideh Sheahan:
ReplyDeleteMy name is Farideh Sheahan and I have been the teacher of NUVHS for Persian course since last year. I have not had many students so far, but I try to stay in close contact with the students and grade their work on time. Some times I have made myself available for the students to call me and review their lessons and ask questions. Couple of the students have been re-enrolling for couple of semesters. I would like to think that they are happy about the course and their progress and that is why they keep coming back.
I really like seeing returning students in my math courses. I teach most levels and it's great to see their progression. I think it makes such a difference to them when we can build and maintain these relationships.
DeleteI teach physical education courses with NUVHS. I have had the privilege of teaching some of same students over the last couple semesters.
ReplyDeleteOne way that I hold high expectations for my student is to facilitate meaningful dialogue in their discussions. Students must not only state their experience with certain physical activities, they must also comment and critique another student's work.
Another strategy of high expectations for students is offering high quality feedback. This is a way that I can facilitate learning and provide students with clear sense of how they are doing in my class.
I agree that specific personalized feedback is essential. This is especially important with writing in order to move out of formulaic writing since there isn't an equation that will do this. However, sometimes it is hard to give individual feedback at all times. This is where teacher modeling helps. Also, rubrics for more specific feedback with writing without commenting on every sentence.
DeleteGood afternoon,
ReplyDeleteI actually follow the same approach as many of you have already mentioned. I do allow them to resubmit the assignment. I do the same as Marianne and return the assignment if I notice right away that the overall instructions were not followed. I think holding students to following the instructions in detail is also part of raising the bar. I also let them know my expectations early on in the course. They know what the standards are and that they'll have to work hard for the higher grades. I think allowing them to resubmit the assignments is part of the balance in "being understanding," giving them feedback, and giving them a chance to raise the expectations for themselves next time around.
Jess
It is important to integrate rigor and high expectations into the course. In order for students to reach the high expectations, I have found it helpful to provide This should be done for all assignments including writing. At times, it is helpful to look at good writing and identify what the writer did well and then apply techniques to their own writing. Another method is to evaluate an average example with teacher comments. Students then edit the example paragraph based on teacher comments to improve the analysis/style based on teacher focus/directions. This will hopefully then translate into student writing. Students can also be asked to revise some of their own writing after this direct instruction.
ReplyDeleteAnother way to achieve this is by having students complete quiz/test corrections. Students have to review incorrect responses, chose a new answer and then explain why the new answer is correct using in text evidence to explain answer. Students then receive half the points missed on the question. This promotes student reflection and revision. Hopefully, students will take new information into future quizzes/tests and applications.
No matter the expectations, students need multiple opportunities to demonstrate competency and students should always be given models of expectations so they know what to strive to achieve.
My name is Babak Eskandari and I have been teaching Pre-Calculus classes since 2010. I do expect quality work from my students, especially on their end of the term project. If their homework or discussion postings are not correct I let them redo it. This way they have a chance to learn better and get a higher grade. If they don't turn in an assignment they will receive a zero. I always respond to their questions within 24 to 48 hours and I try to not just to answer their questions, but encourage them to investigate and research more about the topic they asked about.
ReplyDeleteMany of my students are taking my Spanish online courses because they have not passed the same course in their own High Schools, or because it does not fit into their schedule at school in order to finish for college entry, and want to finish both semesters of Spanish II in one online semester. A lot of my students tell me as they start the semester that they do not like learning a second language because they don't think they will do well with it, and/or they have never taken an online course and are overwhelmed with learning how to start the course.
ReplyDeleteI try to be very specific in my directions, and I also encourage them that they need to try their best and that I am always there to help them. My students write to me with lots of questions, which I answer for them. I give them examples of how to do the more difficult grammatical skills, and then have them try on their own to make sure that they understand. Sometimes in Spanish something that seems so insignificant as a missing accent mark can change the tense or the whole meaning of a word, so it is important for the students to learn the correct way to write words and to conjugate verbs. I insist that they need to do their work in Spanish, even though grammar can be a nightmare, and even though they don't think they are capable of doing this at first. As the semester proceeds, students begin to see that they CAN write and speak in Spanish, and they usually tell me by the end of the semester that they love Spanish.
They also really like doing the semester projects where they can cook a typical meal from a Spanish-speaking country, research famous people from the past or soccer players or celebrities from present time that they can write their reports on (also all in Spanish). It is amazing to see what they come up with. They always have a lot of fun with it! Marco
On behalf of Jolene Ericsson...
ReplyDeleteI submit a format like the one Marianne has posted here. I find that it helps (like Jason says) to articulate. I often ask students how they personally felt about the reading once they've submitted their assignment, if they felt the reading was controversial, etc. This sometimes helps to get them thinking in a different direction.
It is great to read all of these good ideas. I would be interested to see Marianne's Guidelines and Recommendations pages. It is also good to know that others have strict policies regarding formatting and incomplete work. Communication of standards is worth the time and effort. Once students understand the expectations, we can all focus on content and mastery.
ReplyDelete