Wednesday, November 14, 2012

Responding to "I don't know."



Questions to ponder from the November 2012 Professional Development:

Think about the classes you teach and brainstorm possible reasons why students in your class might be unable to answer a given question. Is there a question in particular students have historically had trouble with? Is there ever a time when you think students may know the answer but are afraid to write it? What can you do to help students feel confident in their response and master the content?

7 comments:

  1. I have found that I have a couple students who are timid when it comes to asking for help and this definitely shows up on their assignments.

    I've had the most success breaking this barrier of doubt or embarrassment with both praise and humor. We have a unique opportunity in the online environment to contact our students directly and I use this as an opportunity to get to know the student.

    I'm still critical when grading and providing feedback, but I also try to keep the conversation light. I want the student to know that I am there for them and that their opinion and thoughts matter. I also like to incorporate a little humor! I want the students to feel comfortable interacting with me.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I mentioned this in the 11/6 prompt but I thought it was also appropriate here. When reading Shakespeare, many students have difficulty with the Old English language. Many are hesitant to ask for help. I can tell they are struggling with the language because their answers are general and brief or their responses are way off point.

    For students who are obviously having difficulties with Shakespeare's old English, I will point them to websites that have Shakespeare's plays in modern English but retain the story lines.

    I don't believe this is an opt out because I still encourage them to read the original and abridged versions. I find this helps them enjoy Shakespeare without getting too frustrated in the language.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I don't think I ever had a student(during my online teach experience) who was afraid of answering a question. I have had students who e-mailed me and said "I don't understand."
    When this happens, I try to ask questions to find out what specific area they are having difficulty with, because usually it's not the whole problem that they don't understand, but parts of it. When I ask questions then they start thinking more about the problem and this helps them to understand the problem better and gain more confidence that they can solve the problem. Of course, I will help them by giving them hints on how to proceed.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I have students who have said, "I don't know" or even "This question is not from the unit." Sometimes they are very frustrated and defensive about not understanding something, so I like the idea of using praise and humor. Humor helps students to release the frustration and praise is good because we can then build upon success, even if the success is simply being able to express their need for more information. I thank students for asking questions.
    Once the dialogue starts, I like to show the student how he or she can start from what they know to formulate a specific question. A general comment like "I don't get this chapter" will usually have a response like "What is confusing about this chapter?" or "Which part of the question is confusing?" (Being confused is more positive/less threatening than not knowing.) Through more communication, we can usually get to the point of confusion. By this time, the student has had time to be more analytical in thinking about the issue, and has used academic language to explain the question specifically. Next, I either point the student to resources or will answer a similar question, leaving the student to return to the original question with the information needed to be successful.
    Students gain confidence when they overcome a problem and learn how to go about getting the information they need to be successful.

    ReplyDelete
  5. My students have questions in the beginning of the course. Usually, I try to demystify any questions students may have from the start of class.

    I do not believe that students feel "timid" when they write their discussion. My class environment is comfortable for students to express their ideas without feeling judged for it.

    When I feel that a student is capable of expanding on a concept, I will ask for more detail or even where their answer derived from. It is important for instructors to give continuous praise as they ask for more details from their students. This will help students feel safe and confident in their responses.

    ReplyDelete
  6. There are many topics in math (or aspects of math class) that can be points of confusion. So I actually email frequent short announcements that clarify points that students in previous terms found confusing. By frequent I mean two or three times per week.

    Some examples are:
    -- How to use the dropboxes
    -- Five different ways to get a hold of me
    -- Reminders of the many ways I can help them if they're stuck
    -- Reminders to complete the student questionnaire
    -- Reminders that they can rework homework problems
    -- Reminders to check their gradebook and email frequently
    -- Where to find web-based calculators
    -- Websites with graphing calculator tutorials
    -- Hints for using the MyMathLab toolbars
    -- Suggestions to start their projects early
    -- Suggestions to allow extra time for the trigonometry units


    Sending frequent emails has the side-benefit of making students know I'm available for them and that I'm thinking about them. I hear stories from new students about their experiences at other online schools they attended where they had zero interaction with their teacher. That REALLY bothers me. So I want their experience with me to be the opposite.

    I also think that frequent emails help to keep my class in their minds. After I send an announcement, I usually get a few students who hit reply and ask me an unrelated question.

    When a student asks a math question I will often type one of these as the first sentence in my reply:

    --- I'm glad to hear from you.
    --- I'm glad you're asking about that.
    --- A lot of students ask that question.
    --- A lot of students have a hard time with that.
    --- That's one of the hardest topics this semester.

    I figure it will help them feel less intimidated if they know that other students struggle with the same thing. Once I can get communication going then I continue to use positive language, and I provide examples, tutorials, and whatever other resources they might need.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I try to use the student questions and information to improve on the class each semester. If there was a problem with certain questions or assignments, I will see if the assignments are easily understood, try to explain them better or develop a new assignment for that topic.

    I try to send regular emails to the students and often try to call them to show that I am here for their assistance. I try to put a positive comment in each email. Sometimes that is not easy, but I do try.

    One problem I struggle with is getting students to ask a specific question. Many times students will say I don't understand assignment 4. Which part of assignment 4? I don't want to overwhelm them with information they already understand, and I don't want to take too much time with what is your question? is it part A or part B? That can cause the student to give up and just move on - so I am still struggling with that part myself.

    I really feel that communication is the key. Whether the classes are in person or online, communication needs to exist between teacher, student and parent/guardian. With communication we will get everything figured out - some "things" just might take longer than others.

    ReplyDelete